1
1
openmpi/orte/mca/rmaps/round_robin/rmaps_rr.c

511 строки
19 KiB
C
Исходник Обычный вид История

/*
* Copyright (c) 2004-2005 The Trustees of Indiana University and Indiana
* University Research and Technology
* Corporation. All rights reserved.
* Copyright (c) 2004-2005 The University of Tennessee and The University
* of Tennessee Research Foundation. All rights
* reserved.
* Copyright (c) 2004-2005 High Performance Computing Center Stuttgart,
* University of Stuttgart. All rights reserved.
* Copyright (c) 2004-2005 The Regents of the University of California.
* All rights reserved.
* Copyright (c) 2006 Cisco Systems, Inc. All rights reserved.
* $COPYRIGHT$
*
* Additional copyrights may follow
*
* $HEADER$
*/
#include "orte_config.h"
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
#include "orte/orte_constants.h"
#include "orte/orte_types.h"
#include <errno.h>
#ifdef HAVE_UNISTD_H
#include <unistd.h>
#endif /* HAVE_UNISTD_H */
#ifdef HAVE_STRING_H
#include <string.h>
#endif /* HAVE_STRING_H */
#include "opal/mca/base/mca_base_param.h"
#include "opal/util/output.h"
#include "opal/util/show_help.h"
#include "opal/util/argv.h"
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
#include "orte/mca/errmgr/errmgr.h"
#include "orte/mca/ns/ns.h"
#include "orte/mca/gpr/gpr.h"
#include "orte/mca/rmaps/base/base.h"
#include "orte/mca/rmgr/base/base.h"
#include "orte/mca/rmaps/base/rmaps_base_map.h"
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
#include "orte/mca/rmaps/base/rmaps_base_node.h"
#include "rmaps_rr.h"
/*
(copied from a mail that has a lengthy description of this commit) I spoke with Tim about this the other day -- he gave me the green light to go ahead with this, but it turned into a bigger job than I thought it would be. I revamped how the default RAS scheduling and round_robin RMAPS mapping occurs. The previous algorithms were pretty brain dead, and ignored the "slots" and "max_slots" tokens in hostfiles. I considered this a big enough problem to fix it for the beta (because there is currently no way to control where processes are launched on SMPs). There's still some more bells and whistles that I'd like to implement, but there's no hurry, and they can go on the trunk at any time. My patches below are for what I considered "essential", and do the following: - honor the "slots" and "max-slots" tokens in the hostfile (and all their synonyms), meaning that we allocate/map until we fill slots, and if there are still more processes to allocate/map, we keep going until we fill max-slots (i.e., only oversubscribe a node if we have to). - offer two different algorithms, currently supported by two new options to orterun. Remember that there are two parts here -- slot allocation and process mapping. Slot allocation controls how many processes we'll be running on a node. After that decision has been made, process mapping effectively controls where the ranks of MPI_COMM_WORLD (MCW) are placed. Some of the examples given below don't make sense unless you remember that there is a difference between the two (which makes total sense, but you have to think about it in terms of both things): 1. "-bynode": allocates/maps one process per node in a round-robin fashion until all slots on the node are taken. If we still have more processes after all slots are taken, then keep going until all max-slots are taken. Examples: - The hostfile: eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -bynode -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until each node's max_slots is hit, of course) - orterun -bynode -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4, 6 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 2. "-byslot" (this is the default if you don't specify -bynode): greedily takes all available slots on a node for a job before moving on to the next node. If we still have processes to allocate/schedule, then oversubscribe all nodes equally (i.e., go round robin on all nodes until each node's max_slots is hit). Examples: - The hostfile eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1 vogon: MCW ranks 2, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until max_slots is hit) - orterun -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2, 3 vogon: MCW ranks 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 The above examples are fairly contrived, and it's not clear from them that you can get different allocation answers in all cases (the mapping differences are obvious). Consider the following allocation example: - The hostfile eddie count=4 vogon count=4 earth count=4 deep-thought count=4 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 4 slots will be allocated vogon: 4 slots will be allocated earth: no slots allocated deep-thought: no slots allocated - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 2 slots will be allocated vogon: 2 slots will be allocated earth: 2 slots will be allocated deep-thought: 2 slots will be allocated This commit was SVN r5894.
2005-05-31 20:36:53 +04:00
* Local variable
*/
static opal_list_item_t *cur_node_item = NULL;
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
static opal_list_t fully_used_nodes;
(copied from a mail that has a lengthy description of this commit) I spoke with Tim about this the other day -- he gave me the green light to go ahead with this, but it turned into a bigger job than I thought it would be. I revamped how the default RAS scheduling and round_robin RMAPS mapping occurs. The previous algorithms were pretty brain dead, and ignored the "slots" and "max_slots" tokens in hostfiles. I considered this a big enough problem to fix it for the beta (because there is currently no way to control where processes are launched on SMPs). There's still some more bells and whistles that I'd like to implement, but there's no hurry, and they can go on the trunk at any time. My patches below are for what I considered "essential", and do the following: - honor the "slots" and "max-slots" tokens in the hostfile (and all their synonyms), meaning that we allocate/map until we fill slots, and if there are still more processes to allocate/map, we keep going until we fill max-slots (i.e., only oversubscribe a node if we have to). - offer two different algorithms, currently supported by two new options to orterun. Remember that there are two parts here -- slot allocation and process mapping. Slot allocation controls how many processes we'll be running on a node. After that decision has been made, process mapping effectively controls where the ranks of MPI_COMM_WORLD (MCW) are placed. Some of the examples given below don't make sense unless you remember that there is a difference between the two (which makes total sense, but you have to think about it in terms of both things): 1. "-bynode": allocates/maps one process per node in a round-robin fashion until all slots on the node are taken. If we still have more processes after all slots are taken, then keep going until all max-slots are taken. Examples: - The hostfile: eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -bynode -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until each node's max_slots is hit, of course) - orterun -bynode -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4, 6 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 2. "-byslot" (this is the default if you don't specify -bynode): greedily takes all available slots on a node for a job before moving on to the next node. If we still have processes to allocate/schedule, then oversubscribe all nodes equally (i.e., go round robin on all nodes until each node's max_slots is hit). Examples: - The hostfile eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1 vogon: MCW ranks 2, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until max_slots is hit) - orterun -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2, 3 vogon: MCW ranks 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 The above examples are fairly contrived, and it's not clear from them that you can get different allocation answers in all cases (the mapping differences are obvious). Consider the following allocation example: - The hostfile eddie count=4 vogon count=4 earth count=4 deep-thought count=4 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 4 slots will be allocated vogon: 4 slots will be allocated earth: no slots allocated deep-thought: no slots allocated - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 2 slots will be allocated vogon: 2 slots will be allocated earth: 2 slots will be allocated deep-thought: 2 slots will be allocated This commit was SVN r5894.
2005-05-31 20:36:53 +04:00
/*
* Create a default mapping for the application, scheduling round
* robin by node.
*/
static int map_app_by_node(
orte_app_context_t* app,
orte_rmaps_base_map_t* map,
orte_jobid_t jobid,
orte_vpid_t vpid_start,
int rank,
opal_list_t* nodes,
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
opal_list_t* max_used_nodes)
{
int rc = ORTE_SUCCESS;
size_t num_alloc = 0;
size_t proc_index = 0;
opal_list_item_t *next;
Quite a range of small changes. ns_replica.c - Removed the error logging since I use this function in orte_init_stage1 to check if we have created a cellid yet or not. ras_types.h & rase_base_node.h - This was an empty file. moved the orte_ras_node_t from base/ras_base_node.h to this file. - Changed the name of orte_ras_base_node_t to orte_ras_node_t to match the naming mechanisms in place. ras.h - Exposed 2 functions: - node_insert: This takes a list of orte_ras_base_node_t's and places them in the Node Segment of the GPR. This is to be used in orte_init_stage1 for singleton processes, and the hostfile parsing (see rds_hostfile.c). This just puts in the appropriate API interface to keep from calling the orte_ras_base_node_insert function directly. - node_query: This is used in hostfile parsing. This just puts in the appropriate API interface to keep from calling the orte_ras_base_node_query function directly. - Touched all of the implemented components to add reference to these new function pointers ras_base_select.c & ras_base_open.c - Add and set the global module reference rds.h - Exposed 1 function: - store_resource: This stores a list of rds_cell_desc_t's to the Resource Segment. This is used in conjunction with the orte_ras.node_insert function in both the orte_init_stage1 for singleton processes and rds_hostfile.c rds_base_select.c & rds_base_open.c - Add and set the global module reference rds_hostfile.c - Added functionality to create a new cellid for each hostfile, placing each entry in the hostfile into the same cellid. Currently this is commented out with the cellid hard coded to 0, with the intention of taking this out once ORTE is able to handle multiple cellid's - Instead of just adding hosts to the Node Segment via a direct call to the ras_base_node_insert() function. First add the hosts to the Resource Segment of the GPR using the orte_rds.store_resource() function then use the API version of orte_ras.node_insert() to store the hosts on the Node Segment. - Add 1 new function pointer to module as required by the API. rds_hostfile_component.c - Converted this to use the new MCA parameter registration orte_init_stage1.c - It is possible that a cellid was not created yet for the current environment. So I put in some logic to test if the cellid 0 existed. If it does then continue, otherwise create the cellid so we can properly interact with the GPR via the RDS. - For the singleton case we insert some 'dummy' data into the GPR. The RAS matches this logic, so I took out the duplicate GPR put logic, and replaced it with a call to the orte_ras.node_insert() function. - Further before calling orte_ras.node_insert() in the singleton case, we also call orte_rds.store_resource() to add the singleton node to the Resource Segment. Console: - Added a bunch of new functions. Still experimenting with many aspects of the implementation. This is a checkpoint, and has very limited functionality. - Should not be considered stable at the moment. This commit was SVN r6813.
2005-08-11 23:51:50 +04:00
orte_ras_node_t *node;
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
(copied from a mail that has a lengthy description of this commit) I spoke with Tim about this the other day -- he gave me the green light to go ahead with this, but it turned into a bigger job than I thought it would be. I revamped how the default RAS scheduling and round_robin RMAPS mapping occurs. The previous algorithms were pretty brain dead, and ignored the "slots" and "max_slots" tokens in hostfiles. I considered this a big enough problem to fix it for the beta (because there is currently no way to control where processes are launched on SMPs). There's still some more bells and whistles that I'd like to implement, but there's no hurry, and they can go on the trunk at any time. My patches below are for what I considered "essential", and do the following: - honor the "slots" and "max-slots" tokens in the hostfile (and all their synonyms), meaning that we allocate/map until we fill slots, and if there are still more processes to allocate/map, we keep going until we fill max-slots (i.e., only oversubscribe a node if we have to). - offer two different algorithms, currently supported by two new options to orterun. Remember that there are two parts here -- slot allocation and process mapping. Slot allocation controls how many processes we'll be running on a node. After that decision has been made, process mapping effectively controls where the ranks of MPI_COMM_WORLD (MCW) are placed. Some of the examples given below don't make sense unless you remember that there is a difference between the two (which makes total sense, but you have to think about it in terms of both things): 1. "-bynode": allocates/maps one process per node in a round-robin fashion until all slots on the node are taken. If we still have more processes after all slots are taken, then keep going until all max-slots are taken. Examples: - The hostfile: eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -bynode -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until each node's max_slots is hit, of course) - orterun -bynode -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4, 6 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 2. "-byslot" (this is the default if you don't specify -bynode): greedily takes all available slots on a node for a job before moving on to the next node. If we still have processes to allocate/schedule, then oversubscribe all nodes equally (i.e., go round robin on all nodes until each node's max_slots is hit). Examples: - The hostfile eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1 vogon: MCW ranks 2, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until max_slots is hit) - orterun -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2, 3 vogon: MCW ranks 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 The above examples are fairly contrived, and it's not clear from them that you can get different allocation answers in all cases (the mapping differences are obvious). Consider the following allocation example: - The hostfile eddie count=4 vogon count=4 earth count=4 deep-thought count=4 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 4 slots will be allocated vogon: 4 slots will be allocated earth: no slots allocated deep-thought: no slots allocated - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 2 slots will be allocated vogon: 2 slots will be allocated earth: 2 slots will be allocated deep-thought: 2 slots will be allocated This commit was SVN r5894.
2005-05-31 20:36:53 +04:00
/* This loop continues until all procs have been mapped or we run
out of resources. We determine that we have "run out of
resources" when all nodes have node_slots_max processes mapped to them,
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
thus there are no free slots for a process to be mapped, or we have
hit the soft limit on all nodes and are in a "no oversubscribe" state.
If we still have processes that haven't been mapped yet, then it's an
"out of resources" error.
In this scenario, we rely on the claim_slot function to handle the
oversubscribed case. The claim_slot function will leave a node on the
list until it either reachs node_slots_max OR reaches node_slots (the
soft limit) and the "no_oversubscribe" flag has been set - at which point,
the node will be removed to prevent any more processes from being mapped to
it. Since we are taking one slot from each node as we cycle through, the
list, oversubscription is automatically taken care of via this logic.
*/
(copied from a mail that has a lengthy description of this commit) I spoke with Tim about this the other day -- he gave me the green light to go ahead with this, but it turned into a bigger job than I thought it would be. I revamped how the default RAS scheduling and round_robin RMAPS mapping occurs. The previous algorithms were pretty brain dead, and ignored the "slots" and "max_slots" tokens in hostfiles. I considered this a big enough problem to fix it for the beta (because there is currently no way to control where processes are launched on SMPs). There's still some more bells and whistles that I'd like to implement, but there's no hurry, and they can go on the trunk at any time. My patches below are for what I considered "essential", and do the following: - honor the "slots" and "max-slots" tokens in the hostfile (and all their synonyms), meaning that we allocate/map until we fill slots, and if there are still more processes to allocate/map, we keep going until we fill max-slots (i.e., only oversubscribe a node if we have to). - offer two different algorithms, currently supported by two new options to orterun. Remember that there are two parts here -- slot allocation and process mapping. Slot allocation controls how many processes we'll be running on a node. After that decision has been made, process mapping effectively controls where the ranks of MPI_COMM_WORLD (MCW) are placed. Some of the examples given below don't make sense unless you remember that there is a difference between the two (which makes total sense, but you have to think about it in terms of both things): 1. "-bynode": allocates/maps one process per node in a round-robin fashion until all slots on the node are taken. If we still have more processes after all slots are taken, then keep going until all max-slots are taken. Examples: - The hostfile: eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -bynode -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until each node's max_slots is hit, of course) - orterun -bynode -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4, 6 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 2. "-byslot" (this is the default if you don't specify -bynode): greedily takes all available slots on a node for a job before moving on to the next node. If we still have processes to allocate/schedule, then oversubscribe all nodes equally (i.e., go round robin on all nodes until each node's max_slots is hit). Examples: - The hostfile eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1 vogon: MCW ranks 2, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until max_slots is hit) - orterun -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2, 3 vogon: MCW ranks 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 The above examples are fairly contrived, and it's not clear from them that you can get different allocation answers in all cases (the mapping differences are obvious). Consider the following allocation example: - The hostfile eddie count=4 vogon count=4 earth count=4 deep-thought count=4 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 4 slots will be allocated vogon: 4 slots will be allocated earth: no slots allocated deep-thought: no slots allocated - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 2 slots will be allocated vogon: 2 slots will be allocated earth: 2 slots will be allocated deep-thought: 2 slots will be allocated This commit was SVN r5894.
2005-05-31 20:36:53 +04:00
while (num_alloc < app->num_procs) {
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
/** see if any nodes remain unused and available. We need to do this check
* each time since we may remove nodes from the list (as they become fully
* used) as we cycle through the loop */
if(0 >= opal_list_get_size(nodes) ) {
/* No more nodes to allocate :( */
opal_show_help("help-orte-rmaps-rr.txt", "orte-rmaps-rr:alloc-error",
true, app->num_procs, app->app);
ORTE_ERROR_LOG(ORTE_ERR_OUT_OF_RESOURCE);
return ORTE_ERR_OUT_OF_RESOURCE;
}
/* Save the next node we can use before claiming slots, since
* we may need to prune the nodes list removing overused nodes.
* Wrap around to beginning if we are at the end of the list */
if (opal_list_get_end(nodes) == opal_list_get_next(cur_node_item)) {
next = opal_list_get_first(nodes);
}
else {
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
next = opal_list_get_next(cur_node_item);
}
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
/* Allocate a slot on this node */
node = (orte_ras_node_t*) cur_node_item;
if (ORTE_SUCCESS != (rc = orte_rmaps_base_claim_slot(map, node, jobid, vpid_start + rank, proc_index,
nodes, max_used_nodes))) {
ORTE_ERROR_LOG(rc);
return rc;
}
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
++rank;
++proc_index;
++num_alloc;
(copied from a mail that has a lengthy description of this commit) I spoke with Tim about this the other day -- he gave me the green light to go ahead with this, but it turned into a bigger job than I thought it would be. I revamped how the default RAS scheduling and round_robin RMAPS mapping occurs. The previous algorithms were pretty brain dead, and ignored the "slots" and "max_slots" tokens in hostfiles. I considered this a big enough problem to fix it for the beta (because there is currently no way to control where processes are launched on SMPs). There's still some more bells and whistles that I'd like to implement, but there's no hurry, and they can go on the trunk at any time. My patches below are for what I considered "essential", and do the following: - honor the "slots" and "max-slots" tokens in the hostfile (and all their synonyms), meaning that we allocate/map until we fill slots, and if there are still more processes to allocate/map, we keep going until we fill max-slots (i.e., only oversubscribe a node if we have to). - offer two different algorithms, currently supported by two new options to orterun. Remember that there are two parts here -- slot allocation and process mapping. Slot allocation controls how many processes we'll be running on a node. After that decision has been made, process mapping effectively controls where the ranks of MPI_COMM_WORLD (MCW) are placed. Some of the examples given below don't make sense unless you remember that there is a difference between the two (which makes total sense, but you have to think about it in terms of both things): 1. "-bynode": allocates/maps one process per node in a round-robin fashion until all slots on the node are taken. If we still have more processes after all slots are taken, then keep going until all max-slots are taken. Examples: - The hostfile: eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -bynode -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until each node's max_slots is hit, of course) - orterun -bynode -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4, 6 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 2. "-byslot" (this is the default if you don't specify -bynode): greedily takes all available slots on a node for a job before moving on to the next node. If we still have processes to allocate/schedule, then oversubscribe all nodes equally (i.e., go round robin on all nodes until each node's max_slots is hit). Examples: - The hostfile eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1 vogon: MCW ranks 2, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until max_slots is hit) - orterun -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2, 3 vogon: MCW ranks 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 The above examples are fairly contrived, and it's not clear from them that you can get different allocation answers in all cases (the mapping differences are obvious). Consider the following allocation example: - The hostfile eddie count=4 vogon count=4 earth count=4 deep-thought count=4 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 4 slots will be allocated vogon: 4 slots will be allocated earth: no slots allocated deep-thought: no slots allocated - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 2 slots will be allocated vogon: 2 slots will be allocated earth: 2 slots will be allocated deep-thought: 2 slots will be allocated This commit was SVN r5894.
2005-05-31 20:36:53 +04:00
cur_node_item = next;
}
(copied from a mail that has a lengthy description of this commit) I spoke with Tim about this the other day -- he gave me the green light to go ahead with this, but it turned into a bigger job than I thought it would be. I revamped how the default RAS scheduling and round_robin RMAPS mapping occurs. The previous algorithms were pretty brain dead, and ignored the "slots" and "max_slots" tokens in hostfiles. I considered this a big enough problem to fix it for the beta (because there is currently no way to control where processes are launched on SMPs). There's still some more bells and whistles that I'd like to implement, but there's no hurry, and they can go on the trunk at any time. My patches below are for what I considered "essential", and do the following: - honor the "slots" and "max-slots" tokens in the hostfile (and all their synonyms), meaning that we allocate/map until we fill slots, and if there are still more processes to allocate/map, we keep going until we fill max-slots (i.e., only oversubscribe a node if we have to). - offer two different algorithms, currently supported by two new options to orterun. Remember that there are two parts here -- slot allocation and process mapping. Slot allocation controls how many processes we'll be running on a node. After that decision has been made, process mapping effectively controls where the ranks of MPI_COMM_WORLD (MCW) are placed. Some of the examples given below don't make sense unless you remember that there is a difference between the two (which makes total sense, but you have to think about it in terms of both things): 1. "-bynode": allocates/maps one process per node in a round-robin fashion until all slots on the node are taken. If we still have more processes after all slots are taken, then keep going until all max-slots are taken. Examples: - The hostfile: eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -bynode -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until each node's max_slots is hit, of course) - orterun -bynode -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4, 6 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 2. "-byslot" (this is the default if you don't specify -bynode): greedily takes all available slots on a node for a job before moving on to the next node. If we still have processes to allocate/schedule, then oversubscribe all nodes equally (i.e., go round robin on all nodes until each node's max_slots is hit). Examples: - The hostfile eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1 vogon: MCW ranks 2, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until max_slots is hit) - orterun -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2, 3 vogon: MCW ranks 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 The above examples are fairly contrived, and it's not clear from them that you can get different allocation answers in all cases (the mapping differences are obvious). Consider the following allocation example: - The hostfile eddie count=4 vogon count=4 earth count=4 deep-thought count=4 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 4 slots will be allocated vogon: 4 slots will be allocated earth: no slots allocated deep-thought: no slots allocated - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 2 slots will be allocated vogon: 2 slots will be allocated earth: 2 slots will be allocated deep-thought: 2 slots will be allocated This commit was SVN r5894.
2005-05-31 20:36:53 +04:00
map->num_procs = num_alloc;
(copied from a mail that has a lengthy description of this commit) I spoke with Tim about this the other day -- he gave me the green light to go ahead with this, but it turned into a bigger job than I thought it would be. I revamped how the default RAS scheduling and round_robin RMAPS mapping occurs. The previous algorithms were pretty brain dead, and ignored the "slots" and "max_slots" tokens in hostfiles. I considered this a big enough problem to fix it for the beta (because there is currently no way to control where processes are launched on SMPs). There's still some more bells and whistles that I'd like to implement, but there's no hurry, and they can go on the trunk at any time. My patches below are for what I considered "essential", and do the following: - honor the "slots" and "max-slots" tokens in the hostfile (and all their synonyms), meaning that we allocate/map until we fill slots, and if there are still more processes to allocate/map, we keep going until we fill max-slots (i.e., only oversubscribe a node if we have to). - offer two different algorithms, currently supported by two new options to orterun. Remember that there are two parts here -- slot allocation and process mapping. Slot allocation controls how many processes we'll be running on a node. After that decision has been made, process mapping effectively controls where the ranks of MPI_COMM_WORLD (MCW) are placed. Some of the examples given below don't make sense unless you remember that there is a difference between the two (which makes total sense, but you have to think about it in terms of both things): 1. "-bynode": allocates/maps one process per node in a round-robin fashion until all slots on the node are taken. If we still have more processes after all slots are taken, then keep going until all max-slots are taken. Examples: - The hostfile: eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -bynode -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until each node's max_slots is hit, of course) - orterun -bynode -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4, 6 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 2. "-byslot" (this is the default if you don't specify -bynode): greedily takes all available slots on a node for a job before moving on to the next node. If we still have processes to allocate/schedule, then oversubscribe all nodes equally (i.e., go round robin on all nodes until each node's max_slots is hit). Examples: - The hostfile eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1 vogon: MCW ranks 2, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until max_slots is hit) - orterun -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2, 3 vogon: MCW ranks 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 The above examples are fairly contrived, and it's not clear from them that you can get different allocation answers in all cases (the mapping differences are obvious). Consider the following allocation example: - The hostfile eddie count=4 vogon count=4 earth count=4 deep-thought count=4 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 4 slots will be allocated vogon: 4 slots will be allocated earth: no slots allocated deep-thought: no slots allocated - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 2 slots will be allocated vogon: 2 slots will be allocated earth: 2 slots will be allocated deep-thought: 2 slots will be allocated This commit was SVN r5894.
2005-05-31 20:36:53 +04:00
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
return ORTE_SUCCESS;
(copied from a mail that has a lengthy description of this commit) I spoke with Tim about this the other day -- he gave me the green light to go ahead with this, but it turned into a bigger job than I thought it would be. I revamped how the default RAS scheduling and round_robin RMAPS mapping occurs. The previous algorithms were pretty brain dead, and ignored the "slots" and "max_slots" tokens in hostfiles. I considered this a big enough problem to fix it for the beta (because there is currently no way to control where processes are launched on SMPs). There's still some more bells and whistles that I'd like to implement, but there's no hurry, and they can go on the trunk at any time. My patches below are for what I considered "essential", and do the following: - honor the "slots" and "max-slots" tokens in the hostfile (and all their synonyms), meaning that we allocate/map until we fill slots, and if there are still more processes to allocate/map, we keep going until we fill max-slots (i.e., only oversubscribe a node if we have to). - offer two different algorithms, currently supported by two new options to orterun. Remember that there are two parts here -- slot allocation and process mapping. Slot allocation controls how many processes we'll be running on a node. After that decision has been made, process mapping effectively controls where the ranks of MPI_COMM_WORLD (MCW) are placed. Some of the examples given below don't make sense unless you remember that there is a difference between the two (which makes total sense, but you have to think about it in terms of both things): 1. "-bynode": allocates/maps one process per node in a round-robin fashion until all slots on the node are taken. If we still have more processes after all slots are taken, then keep going until all max-slots are taken. Examples: - The hostfile: eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -bynode -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until each node's max_slots is hit, of course) - orterun -bynode -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4, 6 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 2. "-byslot" (this is the default if you don't specify -bynode): greedily takes all available slots on a node for a job before moving on to the next node. If we still have processes to allocate/schedule, then oversubscribe all nodes equally (i.e., go round robin on all nodes until each node's max_slots is hit). Examples: - The hostfile eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1 vogon: MCW ranks 2, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until max_slots is hit) - orterun -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2, 3 vogon: MCW ranks 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 The above examples are fairly contrived, and it's not clear from them that you can get different allocation answers in all cases (the mapping differences are obvious). Consider the following allocation example: - The hostfile eddie count=4 vogon count=4 earth count=4 deep-thought count=4 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 4 slots will be allocated vogon: 4 slots will be allocated earth: no slots allocated deep-thought: no slots allocated - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 2 slots will be allocated vogon: 2 slots will be allocated earth: 2 slots will be allocated deep-thought: 2 slots will be allocated This commit was SVN r5894.
2005-05-31 20:36:53 +04:00
}
/*
* Create a default mapping for the application, scheduling one round
* robin by slot.
*/
static int map_app_by_slot(
orte_app_context_t* app,
(copied from a mail that has a lengthy description of this commit) I spoke with Tim about this the other day -- he gave me the green light to go ahead with this, but it turned into a bigger job than I thought it would be. I revamped how the default RAS scheduling and round_robin RMAPS mapping occurs. The previous algorithms were pretty brain dead, and ignored the "slots" and "max_slots" tokens in hostfiles. I considered this a big enough problem to fix it for the beta (because there is currently no way to control where processes are launched on SMPs). There's still some more bells and whistles that I'd like to implement, but there's no hurry, and they can go on the trunk at any time. My patches below are for what I considered "essential", and do the following: - honor the "slots" and "max-slots" tokens in the hostfile (and all their synonyms), meaning that we allocate/map until we fill slots, and if there are still more processes to allocate/map, we keep going until we fill max-slots (i.e., only oversubscribe a node if we have to). - offer two different algorithms, currently supported by two new options to orterun. Remember that there are two parts here -- slot allocation and process mapping. Slot allocation controls how many processes we'll be running on a node. After that decision has been made, process mapping effectively controls where the ranks of MPI_COMM_WORLD (MCW) are placed. Some of the examples given below don't make sense unless you remember that there is a difference between the two (which makes total sense, but you have to think about it in terms of both things): 1. "-bynode": allocates/maps one process per node in a round-robin fashion until all slots on the node are taken. If we still have more processes after all slots are taken, then keep going until all max-slots are taken. Examples: - The hostfile: eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -bynode -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until each node's max_slots is hit, of course) - orterun -bynode -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4, 6 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 2. "-byslot" (this is the default if you don't specify -bynode): greedily takes all available slots on a node for a job before moving on to the next node. If we still have processes to allocate/schedule, then oversubscribe all nodes equally (i.e., go round robin on all nodes until each node's max_slots is hit). Examples: - The hostfile eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1 vogon: MCW ranks 2, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until max_slots is hit) - orterun -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2, 3 vogon: MCW ranks 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 The above examples are fairly contrived, and it's not clear from them that you can get different allocation answers in all cases (the mapping differences are obvious). Consider the following allocation example: - The hostfile eddie count=4 vogon count=4 earth count=4 deep-thought count=4 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 4 slots will be allocated vogon: 4 slots will be allocated earth: no slots allocated deep-thought: no slots allocated - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 2 slots will be allocated vogon: 2 slots will be allocated earth: 2 slots will be allocated deep-thought: 2 slots will be allocated This commit was SVN r5894.
2005-05-31 20:36:53 +04:00
orte_rmaps_base_map_t* map,
orte_jobid_t jobid,
orte_vpid_t vpid_start,
int rank,
opal_list_t* nodes,
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
opal_list_t* max_used_nodes)
(copied from a mail that has a lengthy description of this commit) I spoke with Tim about this the other day -- he gave me the green light to go ahead with this, but it turned into a bigger job than I thought it would be. I revamped how the default RAS scheduling and round_robin RMAPS mapping occurs. The previous algorithms were pretty brain dead, and ignored the "slots" and "max_slots" tokens in hostfiles. I considered this a big enough problem to fix it for the beta (because there is currently no way to control where processes are launched on SMPs). There's still some more bells and whistles that I'd like to implement, but there's no hurry, and they can go on the trunk at any time. My patches below are for what I considered "essential", and do the following: - honor the "slots" and "max-slots" tokens in the hostfile (and all their synonyms), meaning that we allocate/map until we fill slots, and if there are still more processes to allocate/map, we keep going until we fill max-slots (i.e., only oversubscribe a node if we have to). - offer two different algorithms, currently supported by two new options to orterun. Remember that there are two parts here -- slot allocation and process mapping. Slot allocation controls how many processes we'll be running on a node. After that decision has been made, process mapping effectively controls where the ranks of MPI_COMM_WORLD (MCW) are placed. Some of the examples given below don't make sense unless you remember that there is a difference between the two (which makes total sense, but you have to think about it in terms of both things): 1. "-bynode": allocates/maps one process per node in a round-robin fashion until all slots on the node are taken. If we still have more processes after all slots are taken, then keep going until all max-slots are taken. Examples: - The hostfile: eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -bynode -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until each node's max_slots is hit, of course) - orterun -bynode -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4, 6 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 2. "-byslot" (this is the default if you don't specify -bynode): greedily takes all available slots on a node for a job before moving on to the next node. If we still have processes to allocate/schedule, then oversubscribe all nodes equally (i.e., go round robin on all nodes until each node's max_slots is hit). Examples: - The hostfile eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1 vogon: MCW ranks 2, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until max_slots is hit) - orterun -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2, 3 vogon: MCW ranks 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 The above examples are fairly contrived, and it's not clear from them that you can get different allocation answers in all cases (the mapping differences are obvious). Consider the following allocation example: - The hostfile eddie count=4 vogon count=4 earth count=4 deep-thought count=4 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 4 slots will be allocated vogon: 4 slots will be allocated earth: no slots allocated deep-thought: no slots allocated - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 2 slots will be allocated vogon: 2 slots will be allocated earth: 2 slots will be allocated deep-thought: 2 slots will be allocated This commit was SVN r5894.
2005-05-31 20:36:53 +04:00
{
int rc = ORTE_SUCCESS;
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
size_t i, num_slots_to_take;
(copied from a mail that has a lengthy description of this commit) I spoke with Tim about this the other day -- he gave me the green light to go ahead with this, but it turned into a bigger job than I thought it would be. I revamped how the default RAS scheduling and round_robin RMAPS mapping occurs. The previous algorithms were pretty brain dead, and ignored the "slots" and "max_slots" tokens in hostfiles. I considered this a big enough problem to fix it for the beta (because there is currently no way to control where processes are launched on SMPs). There's still some more bells and whistles that I'd like to implement, but there's no hurry, and they can go on the trunk at any time. My patches below are for what I considered "essential", and do the following: - honor the "slots" and "max-slots" tokens in the hostfile (and all their synonyms), meaning that we allocate/map until we fill slots, and if there are still more processes to allocate/map, we keep going until we fill max-slots (i.e., only oversubscribe a node if we have to). - offer two different algorithms, currently supported by two new options to orterun. Remember that there are two parts here -- slot allocation and process mapping. Slot allocation controls how many processes we'll be running on a node. After that decision has been made, process mapping effectively controls where the ranks of MPI_COMM_WORLD (MCW) are placed. Some of the examples given below don't make sense unless you remember that there is a difference between the two (which makes total sense, but you have to think about it in terms of both things): 1. "-bynode": allocates/maps one process per node in a round-robin fashion until all slots on the node are taken. If we still have more processes after all slots are taken, then keep going until all max-slots are taken. Examples: - The hostfile: eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -bynode -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until each node's max_slots is hit, of course) - orterun -bynode -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4, 6 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 2. "-byslot" (this is the default if you don't specify -bynode): greedily takes all available slots on a node for a job before moving on to the next node. If we still have processes to allocate/schedule, then oversubscribe all nodes equally (i.e., go round robin on all nodes until each node's max_slots is hit). Examples: - The hostfile eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1 vogon: MCW ranks 2, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until max_slots is hit) - orterun -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2, 3 vogon: MCW ranks 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 The above examples are fairly contrived, and it's not clear from them that you can get different allocation answers in all cases (the mapping differences are obvious). Consider the following allocation example: - The hostfile eddie count=4 vogon count=4 earth count=4 deep-thought count=4 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 4 slots will be allocated vogon: 4 slots will be allocated earth: no slots allocated deep-thought: no slots allocated - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 2 slots will be allocated vogon: 2 slots will be allocated earth: 2 slots will be allocated deep-thought: 2 slots will be allocated This commit was SVN r5894.
2005-05-31 20:36:53 +04:00
size_t num_alloc = 0;
size_t proc_index = 0;
Quite a range of small changes. ns_replica.c - Removed the error logging since I use this function in orte_init_stage1 to check if we have created a cellid yet or not. ras_types.h & rase_base_node.h - This was an empty file. moved the orte_ras_node_t from base/ras_base_node.h to this file. - Changed the name of orte_ras_base_node_t to orte_ras_node_t to match the naming mechanisms in place. ras.h - Exposed 2 functions: - node_insert: This takes a list of orte_ras_base_node_t's and places them in the Node Segment of the GPR. This is to be used in orte_init_stage1 for singleton processes, and the hostfile parsing (see rds_hostfile.c). This just puts in the appropriate API interface to keep from calling the orte_ras_base_node_insert function directly. - node_query: This is used in hostfile parsing. This just puts in the appropriate API interface to keep from calling the orte_ras_base_node_query function directly. - Touched all of the implemented components to add reference to these new function pointers ras_base_select.c & ras_base_open.c - Add and set the global module reference rds.h - Exposed 1 function: - store_resource: This stores a list of rds_cell_desc_t's to the Resource Segment. This is used in conjunction with the orte_ras.node_insert function in both the orte_init_stage1 for singleton processes and rds_hostfile.c rds_base_select.c & rds_base_open.c - Add and set the global module reference rds_hostfile.c - Added functionality to create a new cellid for each hostfile, placing each entry in the hostfile into the same cellid. Currently this is commented out with the cellid hard coded to 0, with the intention of taking this out once ORTE is able to handle multiple cellid's - Instead of just adding hosts to the Node Segment via a direct call to the ras_base_node_insert() function. First add the hosts to the Resource Segment of the GPR using the orte_rds.store_resource() function then use the API version of orte_ras.node_insert() to store the hosts on the Node Segment. - Add 1 new function pointer to module as required by the API. rds_hostfile_component.c - Converted this to use the new MCA parameter registration orte_init_stage1.c - It is possible that a cellid was not created yet for the current environment. So I put in some logic to test if the cellid 0 existed. If it does then continue, otherwise create the cellid so we can properly interact with the GPR via the RDS. - For the singleton case we insert some 'dummy' data into the GPR. The RAS matches this logic, so I took out the duplicate GPR put logic, and replaced it with a call to the orte_ras.node_insert() function. - Further before calling orte_ras.node_insert() in the singleton case, we also call orte_rds.store_resource() to add the singleton node to the Resource Segment. Console: - Added a bunch of new functions. Still experimenting with many aspects of the implementation. This is a checkpoint, and has very limited functionality. - Should not be considered stable at the moment. This commit was SVN r6813.
2005-08-11 23:51:50 +04:00
orte_ras_node_t *node;
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
opal_list_item_t *next;
(copied from a mail that has a lengthy description of this commit) I spoke with Tim about this the other day -- he gave me the green light to go ahead with this, but it turned into a bigger job than I thought it would be. I revamped how the default RAS scheduling and round_robin RMAPS mapping occurs. The previous algorithms were pretty brain dead, and ignored the "slots" and "max_slots" tokens in hostfiles. I considered this a big enough problem to fix it for the beta (because there is currently no way to control where processes are launched on SMPs). There's still some more bells and whistles that I'd like to implement, but there's no hurry, and they can go on the trunk at any time. My patches below are for what I considered "essential", and do the following: - honor the "slots" and "max-slots" tokens in the hostfile (and all their synonyms), meaning that we allocate/map until we fill slots, and if there are still more processes to allocate/map, we keep going until we fill max-slots (i.e., only oversubscribe a node if we have to). - offer two different algorithms, currently supported by two new options to orterun. Remember that there are two parts here -- slot allocation and process mapping. Slot allocation controls how many processes we'll be running on a node. After that decision has been made, process mapping effectively controls where the ranks of MPI_COMM_WORLD (MCW) are placed. Some of the examples given below don't make sense unless you remember that there is a difference between the two (which makes total sense, but you have to think about it in terms of both things): 1. "-bynode": allocates/maps one process per node in a round-robin fashion until all slots on the node are taken. If we still have more processes after all slots are taken, then keep going until all max-slots are taken. Examples: - The hostfile: eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -bynode -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until each node's max_slots is hit, of course) - orterun -bynode -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4, 6 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 2. "-byslot" (this is the default if you don't specify -bynode): greedily takes all available slots on a node for a job before moving on to the next node. If we still have processes to allocate/schedule, then oversubscribe all nodes equally (i.e., go round robin on all nodes until each node's max_slots is hit). Examples: - The hostfile eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1 vogon: MCW ranks 2, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until max_slots is hit) - orterun -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2, 3 vogon: MCW ranks 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 The above examples are fairly contrived, and it's not clear from them that you can get different allocation answers in all cases (the mapping differences are obvious). Consider the following allocation example: - The hostfile eddie count=4 vogon count=4 earth count=4 deep-thought count=4 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 4 slots will be allocated vogon: 4 slots will be allocated earth: no slots allocated deep-thought: no slots allocated - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 2 slots will be allocated vogon: 2 slots will be allocated earth: 2 slots will be allocated deep-thought: 2 slots will be allocated This commit was SVN r5894.
2005-05-31 20:36:53 +04:00
/* This loop continues until all procs have been mapped or we run
out of resources. We determine that we have "run out of
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
resources" when either all nodes have node_slots_max processes mapped to them,
(thus there are no free slots for a process to be mapped), OR all nodes
have reached their soft limit and the user directed us to "no oversubscribe".
If we still have processes that haven't been mapped yet, then it's an
"out of resources" error. */
num_alloc = 0;
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
while ( num_alloc < app->num_procs) {
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
/** see if any nodes remain unused and available. We need to do this check
* each time since we may remove nodes from the list (as they become fully
* used) as we cycle through the loop */
if(0 >= opal_list_get_size(nodes) ) {
/* No more nodes to allocate :( */
opal_show_help("help-orte-rmaps-rr.txt", "orte-rmaps-rr:alloc-error",
true, app->num_procs, app->app);
ORTE_ERROR_LOG(ORTE_ERR_OUT_OF_RESOURCE);
return ORTE_ERR_OUT_OF_RESOURCE;
}
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
/* Save the next node we can use before claiming slots, since
* we may need to prune the nodes list removing overused nodes.
* Wrap around to beginning if we are at the end of the list */
if (opal_list_get_end(nodes) == opal_list_get_next(cur_node_item)) {
next = opal_list_get_first(nodes);
}
else {
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
next = opal_list_get_next(cur_node_item);
}
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
/** declare a shorter name for convenience in the code below */
node = (orte_ras_node_t*) cur_node_item;
/* If we have available slots on this node, claim all of them
* If node_slots == 0, assume 1 slot for that node.
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
* JJH - is this assumption fully justified?
*
* If we are now oversubscribing the nodes, then we still take
* a full node_slots from each node until either everything is done,
* or all nodes have hit their hard limit. This preserves the ratio
* of processes between the nodes (e.g., if one node has twice as
* many processes as another before oversubscribing, it will continue
* to do so after oversubscribing).
*/
num_slots_to_take = (node->node_slots == 0) ? 1 : node->node_slots;
for( i = 0; i < num_slots_to_take; ++i) {
if (ORTE_SUCCESS != (rc = orte_rmaps_base_claim_slot(map, node, jobid, vpid_start + rank, proc_index,
nodes, max_used_nodes))) {
/** if the code is ORTE_ERR_NODE_FULLY_USED, then we know this
* really isn't an error - we just need to break from the loop
* since the node is fully used up. For now, just don't report
* an error
*/
if (ORTE_ERR_NODE_FULLY_USED != rc) {
ORTE_ERROR_LOG(rc);
return rc;
}
}
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
/* Record the number of procs allocated */
++num_alloc;
(copied from a mail that has a lengthy description of this commit) I spoke with Tim about this the other day -- he gave me the green light to go ahead with this, but it turned into a bigger job than I thought it would be. I revamped how the default RAS scheduling and round_robin RMAPS mapping occurs. The previous algorithms were pretty brain dead, and ignored the "slots" and "max_slots" tokens in hostfiles. I considered this a big enough problem to fix it for the beta (because there is currently no way to control where processes are launched on SMPs). There's still some more bells and whistles that I'd like to implement, but there's no hurry, and they can go on the trunk at any time. My patches below are for what I considered "essential", and do the following: - honor the "slots" and "max-slots" tokens in the hostfile (and all their synonyms), meaning that we allocate/map until we fill slots, and if there are still more processes to allocate/map, we keep going until we fill max-slots (i.e., only oversubscribe a node if we have to). - offer two different algorithms, currently supported by two new options to orterun. Remember that there are two parts here -- slot allocation and process mapping. Slot allocation controls how many processes we'll be running on a node. After that decision has been made, process mapping effectively controls where the ranks of MPI_COMM_WORLD (MCW) are placed. Some of the examples given below don't make sense unless you remember that there is a difference between the two (which makes total sense, but you have to think about it in terms of both things): 1. "-bynode": allocates/maps one process per node in a round-robin fashion until all slots on the node are taken. If we still have more processes after all slots are taken, then keep going until all max-slots are taken. Examples: - The hostfile: eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -bynode -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until each node's max_slots is hit, of course) - orterun -bynode -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4, 6 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 2. "-byslot" (this is the default if you don't specify -bynode): greedily takes all available slots on a node for a job before moving on to the next node. If we still have processes to allocate/schedule, then oversubscribe all nodes equally (i.e., go round robin on all nodes until each node's max_slots is hit). Examples: - The hostfile eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1 vogon: MCW ranks 2, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until max_slots is hit) - orterun -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2, 3 vogon: MCW ranks 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 The above examples are fairly contrived, and it's not clear from them that you can get different allocation answers in all cases (the mapping differences are obvious). Consider the following allocation example: - The hostfile eddie count=4 vogon count=4 earth count=4 deep-thought count=4 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 4 slots will be allocated vogon: 4 slots will be allocated earth: no slots allocated deep-thought: no slots allocated - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 2 slots will be allocated vogon: 2 slots will be allocated earth: 2 slots will be allocated deep-thought: 2 slots will be allocated This commit was SVN r5894.
2005-05-31 20:36:53 +04:00
++rank;
++proc_index;
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
/** if all the procs have been mapped OR we have fully used up this node, then
* break from the loop
*/
if(num_alloc >= app->num_procs || ORTE_ERR_NODE_FULLY_USED == rc) {
break;
}
(copied from a mail that has a lengthy description of this commit) I spoke with Tim about this the other day -- he gave me the green light to go ahead with this, but it turned into a bigger job than I thought it would be. I revamped how the default RAS scheduling and round_robin RMAPS mapping occurs. The previous algorithms were pretty brain dead, and ignored the "slots" and "max_slots" tokens in hostfiles. I considered this a big enough problem to fix it for the beta (because there is currently no way to control where processes are launched on SMPs). There's still some more bells and whistles that I'd like to implement, but there's no hurry, and they can go on the trunk at any time. My patches below are for what I considered "essential", and do the following: - honor the "slots" and "max-slots" tokens in the hostfile (and all their synonyms), meaning that we allocate/map until we fill slots, and if there are still more processes to allocate/map, we keep going until we fill max-slots (i.e., only oversubscribe a node if we have to). - offer two different algorithms, currently supported by two new options to orterun. Remember that there are two parts here -- slot allocation and process mapping. Slot allocation controls how many processes we'll be running on a node. After that decision has been made, process mapping effectively controls where the ranks of MPI_COMM_WORLD (MCW) are placed. Some of the examples given below don't make sense unless you remember that there is a difference between the two (which makes total sense, but you have to think about it in terms of both things): 1. "-bynode": allocates/maps one process per node in a round-robin fashion until all slots on the node are taken. If we still have more processes after all slots are taken, then keep going until all max-slots are taken. Examples: - The hostfile: eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -bynode -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until each node's max_slots is hit, of course) - orterun -bynode -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4, 6 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 2. "-byslot" (this is the default if you don't specify -bynode): greedily takes all available slots on a node for a job before moving on to the next node. If we still have processes to allocate/schedule, then oversubscribe all nodes equally (i.e., go round robin on all nodes until each node's max_slots is hit). Examples: - The hostfile eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1 vogon: MCW ranks 2, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until max_slots is hit) - orterun -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2, 3 vogon: MCW ranks 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 The above examples are fairly contrived, and it's not clear from them that you can get different allocation answers in all cases (the mapping differences are obvious). Consider the following allocation example: - The hostfile eddie count=4 vogon count=4 earth count=4 deep-thought count=4 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 4 slots will be allocated vogon: 4 slots will be allocated earth: no slots allocated deep-thought: no slots allocated - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 2 slots will be allocated vogon: 2 slots will be allocated earth: 2 slots will be allocated deep-thought: 2 slots will be allocated This commit was SVN r5894.
2005-05-31 20:36:53 +04:00
}
cur_node_item = next;
(copied from a mail that has a lengthy description of this commit) I spoke with Tim about this the other day -- he gave me the green light to go ahead with this, but it turned into a bigger job than I thought it would be. I revamped how the default RAS scheduling and round_robin RMAPS mapping occurs. The previous algorithms were pretty brain dead, and ignored the "slots" and "max_slots" tokens in hostfiles. I considered this a big enough problem to fix it for the beta (because there is currently no way to control where processes are launched on SMPs). There's still some more bells and whistles that I'd like to implement, but there's no hurry, and they can go on the trunk at any time. My patches below are for what I considered "essential", and do the following: - honor the "slots" and "max-slots" tokens in the hostfile (and all their synonyms), meaning that we allocate/map until we fill slots, and if there are still more processes to allocate/map, we keep going until we fill max-slots (i.e., only oversubscribe a node if we have to). - offer two different algorithms, currently supported by two new options to orterun. Remember that there are two parts here -- slot allocation and process mapping. Slot allocation controls how many processes we'll be running on a node. After that decision has been made, process mapping effectively controls where the ranks of MPI_COMM_WORLD (MCW) are placed. Some of the examples given below don't make sense unless you remember that there is a difference between the two (which makes total sense, but you have to think about it in terms of both things): 1. "-bynode": allocates/maps one process per node in a round-robin fashion until all slots on the node are taken. If we still have more processes after all slots are taken, then keep going until all max-slots are taken. Examples: - The hostfile: eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -bynode -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until each node's max_slots is hit, of course) - orterun -bynode -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4, 6 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 2. "-byslot" (this is the default if you don't specify -bynode): greedily takes all available slots on a node for a job before moving on to the next node. If we still have processes to allocate/schedule, then oversubscribe all nodes equally (i.e., go round robin on all nodes until each node's max_slots is hit). Examples: - The hostfile eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1 vogon: MCW ranks 2, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until max_slots is hit) - orterun -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2, 3 vogon: MCW ranks 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 The above examples are fairly contrived, and it's not clear from them that you can get different allocation answers in all cases (the mapping differences are obvious). Consider the following allocation example: - The hostfile eddie count=4 vogon count=4 earth count=4 deep-thought count=4 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 4 slots will be allocated vogon: 4 slots will be allocated earth: no slots allocated deep-thought: no slots allocated - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 2 slots will be allocated vogon: 2 slots will be allocated earth: 2 slots will be allocated deep-thought: 2 slots will be allocated This commit was SVN r5894.
2005-05-31 20:36:53 +04:00
}
(copied from a mail that has a lengthy description of this commit) I spoke with Tim about this the other day -- he gave me the green light to go ahead with this, but it turned into a bigger job than I thought it would be. I revamped how the default RAS scheduling and round_robin RMAPS mapping occurs. The previous algorithms were pretty brain dead, and ignored the "slots" and "max_slots" tokens in hostfiles. I considered this a big enough problem to fix it for the beta (because there is currently no way to control where processes are launched on SMPs). There's still some more bells and whistles that I'd like to implement, but there's no hurry, and they can go on the trunk at any time. My patches below are for what I considered "essential", and do the following: - honor the "slots" and "max-slots" tokens in the hostfile (and all their synonyms), meaning that we allocate/map until we fill slots, and if there are still more processes to allocate/map, we keep going until we fill max-slots (i.e., only oversubscribe a node if we have to). - offer two different algorithms, currently supported by two new options to orterun. Remember that there are two parts here -- slot allocation and process mapping. Slot allocation controls how many processes we'll be running on a node. After that decision has been made, process mapping effectively controls where the ranks of MPI_COMM_WORLD (MCW) are placed. Some of the examples given below don't make sense unless you remember that there is a difference between the two (which makes total sense, but you have to think about it in terms of both things): 1. "-bynode": allocates/maps one process per node in a round-robin fashion until all slots on the node are taken. If we still have more processes after all slots are taken, then keep going until all max-slots are taken. Examples: - The hostfile: eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -bynode -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until each node's max_slots is hit, of course) - orterun -bynode -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4, 6 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 2. "-byslot" (this is the default if you don't specify -bynode): greedily takes all available slots on a node for a job before moving on to the next node. If we still have processes to allocate/schedule, then oversubscribe all nodes equally (i.e., go round robin on all nodes until each node's max_slots is hit). Examples: - The hostfile eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1 vogon: MCW ranks 2, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until max_slots is hit) - orterun -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2, 3 vogon: MCW ranks 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 The above examples are fairly contrived, and it's not clear from them that you can get different allocation answers in all cases (the mapping differences are obvious). Consider the following allocation example: - The hostfile eddie count=4 vogon count=4 earth count=4 deep-thought count=4 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 4 slots will be allocated vogon: 4 slots will be allocated earth: no slots allocated deep-thought: no slots allocated - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 2 slots will be allocated vogon: 2 slots will be allocated earth: 2 slots will be allocated deep-thought: 2 slots will be allocated This commit was SVN r5894.
2005-05-31 20:36:53 +04:00
map->num_procs = num_alloc;
(copied from a mail that has a lengthy description of this commit) I spoke with Tim about this the other day -- he gave me the green light to go ahead with this, but it turned into a bigger job than I thought it would be. I revamped how the default RAS scheduling and round_robin RMAPS mapping occurs. The previous algorithms were pretty brain dead, and ignored the "slots" and "max_slots" tokens in hostfiles. I considered this a big enough problem to fix it for the beta (because there is currently no way to control where processes are launched on SMPs). There's still some more bells and whistles that I'd like to implement, but there's no hurry, and they can go on the trunk at any time. My patches below are for what I considered "essential", and do the following: - honor the "slots" and "max-slots" tokens in the hostfile (and all their synonyms), meaning that we allocate/map until we fill slots, and if there are still more processes to allocate/map, we keep going until we fill max-slots (i.e., only oversubscribe a node if we have to). - offer two different algorithms, currently supported by two new options to orterun. Remember that there are two parts here -- slot allocation and process mapping. Slot allocation controls how many processes we'll be running on a node. After that decision has been made, process mapping effectively controls where the ranks of MPI_COMM_WORLD (MCW) are placed. Some of the examples given below don't make sense unless you remember that there is a difference between the two (which makes total sense, but you have to think about it in terms of both things): 1. "-bynode": allocates/maps one process per node in a round-robin fashion until all slots on the node are taken. If we still have more processes after all slots are taken, then keep going until all max-slots are taken. Examples: - The hostfile: eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -bynode -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until each node's max_slots is hit, of course) - orterun -bynode -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4, 6 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 2. "-byslot" (this is the default if you don't specify -bynode): greedily takes all available slots on a node for a job before moving on to the next node. If we still have processes to allocate/schedule, then oversubscribe all nodes equally (i.e., go round robin on all nodes until each node's max_slots is hit). Examples: - The hostfile eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1 vogon: MCW ranks 2, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until max_slots is hit) - orterun -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2, 3 vogon: MCW ranks 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 The above examples are fairly contrived, and it's not clear from them that you can get different allocation answers in all cases (the mapping differences are obvious). Consider the following allocation example: - The hostfile eddie count=4 vogon count=4 earth count=4 deep-thought count=4 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 4 slots will be allocated vogon: 4 slots will be allocated earth: no slots allocated deep-thought: no slots allocated - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 2 slots will be allocated vogon: 2 slots will be allocated earth: 2 slots will be allocated deep-thought: 2 slots will be allocated This commit was SVN r5894.
2005-05-31 20:36:53 +04:00
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
return ORTE_SUCCESS;
}
/*
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
* Create a round-robin mapping for the job.
*/
static int orte_rmaps_rr_map(orte_jobid_t jobid)
{
orte_app_context_t** context, *app;
orte_rmaps_base_map_t* map;
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
size_t i, num_context;
opal_list_t master_node_list, mapped_node_list, max_used_nodes, *working_node_list;
opal_list_t mapping;
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
opal_list_item_t *item, *item2;
orte_ras_node_t *node, *node2;
orte_vpid_t vpid_start;
size_t num_procs = 0;
int rank = 0;
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
int rc;
(copied from a mail that has a lengthy description of this commit) I spoke with Tim about this the other day -- he gave me the green light to go ahead with this, but it turned into a bigger job than I thought it would be. I revamped how the default RAS scheduling and round_robin RMAPS mapping occurs. The previous algorithms were pretty brain dead, and ignored the "slots" and "max_slots" tokens in hostfiles. I considered this a big enough problem to fix it for the beta (because there is currently no way to control where processes are launched on SMPs). There's still some more bells and whistles that I'd like to implement, but there's no hurry, and they can go on the trunk at any time. My patches below are for what I considered "essential", and do the following: - honor the "slots" and "max-slots" tokens in the hostfile (and all their synonyms), meaning that we allocate/map until we fill slots, and if there are still more processes to allocate/map, we keep going until we fill max-slots (i.e., only oversubscribe a node if we have to). - offer two different algorithms, currently supported by two new options to orterun. Remember that there are two parts here -- slot allocation and process mapping. Slot allocation controls how many processes we'll be running on a node. After that decision has been made, process mapping effectively controls where the ranks of MPI_COMM_WORLD (MCW) are placed. Some of the examples given below don't make sense unless you remember that there is a difference between the two (which makes total sense, but you have to think about it in terms of both things): 1. "-bynode": allocates/maps one process per node in a round-robin fashion until all slots on the node are taken. If we still have more processes after all slots are taken, then keep going until all max-slots are taken. Examples: - The hostfile: eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -bynode -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until each node's max_slots is hit, of course) - orterun -bynode -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4, 6 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 2. "-byslot" (this is the default if you don't specify -bynode): greedily takes all available slots on a node for a job before moving on to the next node. If we still have processes to allocate/schedule, then oversubscribe all nodes equally (i.e., go round robin on all nodes until each node's max_slots is hit). Examples: - The hostfile eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1 vogon: MCW ranks 2, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until max_slots is hit) - orterun -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2, 3 vogon: MCW ranks 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 The above examples are fairly contrived, and it's not clear from them that you can get different allocation answers in all cases (the mapping differences are obvious). Consider the following allocation example: - The hostfile eddie count=4 vogon count=4 earth count=4 deep-thought count=4 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 4 slots will be allocated vogon: 4 slots will be allocated earth: no slots allocated deep-thought: no slots allocated - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 2 slots will be allocated vogon: 2 slots will be allocated earth: 2 slots will be allocated deep-thought: 2 slots will be allocated This commit was SVN r5894.
2005-05-31 20:36:53 +04:00
bool bynode = true;
/* query for the application context and allocated nodes */
if(ORTE_SUCCESS != (rc = orte_rmgr_base_get_app_context(jobid, &context, &num_context))) {
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
ORTE_ERROR_LOG(rc);
return rc;
}
(copied from a mail that has a lengthy description of this commit) I spoke with Tim about this the other day -- he gave me the green light to go ahead with this, but it turned into a bigger job than I thought it would be. I revamped how the default RAS scheduling and round_robin RMAPS mapping occurs. The previous algorithms were pretty brain dead, and ignored the "slots" and "max_slots" tokens in hostfiles. I considered this a big enough problem to fix it for the beta (because there is currently no way to control where processes are launched on SMPs). There's still some more bells and whistles that I'd like to implement, but there's no hurry, and they can go on the trunk at any time. My patches below are for what I considered "essential", and do the following: - honor the "slots" and "max-slots" tokens in the hostfile (and all their synonyms), meaning that we allocate/map until we fill slots, and if there are still more processes to allocate/map, we keep going until we fill max-slots (i.e., only oversubscribe a node if we have to). - offer two different algorithms, currently supported by two new options to orterun. Remember that there are two parts here -- slot allocation and process mapping. Slot allocation controls how many processes we'll be running on a node. After that decision has been made, process mapping effectively controls where the ranks of MPI_COMM_WORLD (MCW) are placed. Some of the examples given below don't make sense unless you remember that there is a difference between the two (which makes total sense, but you have to think about it in terms of both things): 1. "-bynode": allocates/maps one process per node in a round-robin fashion until all slots on the node are taken. If we still have more processes after all slots are taken, then keep going until all max-slots are taken. Examples: - The hostfile: eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -bynode -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until each node's max_slots is hit, of course) - orterun -bynode -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4, 6 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 2. "-byslot" (this is the default if you don't specify -bynode): greedily takes all available slots on a node for a job before moving on to the next node. If we still have processes to allocate/schedule, then oversubscribe all nodes equally (i.e., go round robin on all nodes until each node's max_slots is hit). Examples: - The hostfile eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1 vogon: MCW ranks 2, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until max_slots is hit) - orterun -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2, 3 vogon: MCW ranks 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 The above examples are fairly contrived, and it's not clear from them that you can get different allocation answers in all cases (the mapping differences are obvious). Consider the following allocation example: - The hostfile eddie count=4 vogon count=4 earth count=4 deep-thought count=4 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 4 slots will be allocated vogon: 4 slots will be allocated earth: no slots allocated deep-thought: no slots allocated - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 2 slots will be allocated vogon: 2 slots will be allocated earth: 2 slots will be allocated deep-thought: 2 slots will be allocated This commit was SVN r5894.
2005-05-31 20:36:53 +04:00
/* which policy should we use? */
if (0 == strcmp(mca_rmaps_round_robin_component.schedule_policy, "node")) {
bynode = true;
} else {
bynode = false;
}
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
/* query for all nodes allocated to this job - this will become our master list of
* nodes. From this, we will construct a working list of nodes based on any specified
* mappings from the user
*/
OBJ_CONSTRUCT(&master_node_list, opal_list_t);
if(ORTE_SUCCESS != (rc = orte_rmaps_base_get_target_nodes(&master_node_list, jobid))) {
ORTE_ERROR_LOG(rc);
OBJ_DESTRUCT(&master_node_list);
return rc;
}
/* Total number of procs required
* DEVEL NOTE: Need to extend this when implementing C/N notation
* Will need to set the app->num_procs approprately before this,
* Since we will have the allocated node information at this point.
*/
for(i=0; i<num_context; i++) {
app = context[i];
num_procs += app->num_procs;
}
/* allocate a vpid range for the job */
if(ORTE_SUCCESS != (rc = orte_ns.reserve_range(jobid, num_procs, &vpid_start))) {
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
ORTE_ERROR_LOG(rc);
OBJ_DESTRUCT(&master_node_list);
return rc;
}
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
/* construct a mapping for the job - the list will hold mappings for each
* application context
*/
OBJ_CONSTRUCT(&mapping, opal_list_t);
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
/** initialize the cur_node_item to point to the first node in the list */
cur_node_item = opal_list_get_first(&master_node_list);
/** construct the list to hold any nodes that get fully used during this
* mapping. We need to keep a record of these so we can update their
* information on the registry when we are done, but we want to remove
* them from our master_node_list as we go so we don't keep checking to
* see if we can still map something onto them.
*/
OBJ_CONSTRUCT(&fully_used_nodes, opal_list_t);
/** construct an intermediate list that will hold the nodes that are fully
* used during any one pass through the mapper (i.e., for each app_context).
* we will join the results together to form the fully_used_nodes list. This
* allows us to more efficiently handle the cases where users specify
* the proc-to-node mapping themselves.
*/
OBJ_CONSTRUCT(&max_used_nodes, opal_list_t);
/** construct a list to hold any nodes involved in a user-specified mapping */
OBJ_CONSTRUCT(&mapped_node_list, opal_list_t);
for(i=0; i<num_context; i++) {
app = context[i];
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
/** create a map for this app_context */
map = OBJ_NEW(orte_rmaps_base_map_t);
if(NULL == map) {
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
ORTE_ERROR_LOG(ORTE_ERR_OUT_OF_RESOURCE);
rc = ORTE_ERR_OUT_OF_RESOURCE;
goto cleanup;
}
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
/** add it to the list of mappings for the job */
opal_list_append(&mapping, &map->super);
map->app = app;
(copied from a mail that has a lengthy description of this commit) I spoke with Tim about this the other day -- he gave me the green light to go ahead with this, but it turned into a bigger job than I thought it would be. I revamped how the default RAS scheduling and round_robin RMAPS mapping occurs. The previous algorithms were pretty brain dead, and ignored the "slots" and "max_slots" tokens in hostfiles. I considered this a big enough problem to fix it for the beta (because there is currently no way to control where processes are launched on SMPs). There's still some more bells and whistles that I'd like to implement, but there's no hurry, and they can go on the trunk at any time. My patches below are for what I considered "essential", and do the following: - honor the "slots" and "max-slots" tokens in the hostfile (and all their synonyms), meaning that we allocate/map until we fill slots, and if there are still more processes to allocate/map, we keep going until we fill max-slots (i.e., only oversubscribe a node if we have to). - offer two different algorithms, currently supported by two new options to orterun. Remember that there are two parts here -- slot allocation and process mapping. Slot allocation controls how many processes we'll be running on a node. After that decision has been made, process mapping effectively controls where the ranks of MPI_COMM_WORLD (MCW) are placed. Some of the examples given below don't make sense unless you remember that there is a difference between the two (which makes total sense, but you have to think about it in terms of both things): 1. "-bynode": allocates/maps one process per node in a round-robin fashion until all slots on the node are taken. If we still have more processes after all slots are taken, then keep going until all max-slots are taken. Examples: - The hostfile: eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -bynode -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until each node's max_slots is hit, of course) - orterun -bynode -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4, 6 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 2. "-byslot" (this is the default if you don't specify -bynode): greedily takes all available slots on a node for a job before moving on to the next node. If we still have processes to allocate/schedule, then oversubscribe all nodes equally (i.e., go round robin on all nodes until each node's max_slots is hit). Examples: - The hostfile eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1 vogon: MCW ranks 2, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until max_slots is hit) - orterun -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2, 3 vogon: MCW ranks 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 The above examples are fairly contrived, and it's not clear from them that you can get different allocation answers in all cases (the mapping differences are obvious). Consider the following allocation example: - The hostfile eddie count=4 vogon count=4 earth count=4 deep-thought count=4 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 4 slots will be allocated vogon: 4 slots will be allocated earth: no slots allocated deep-thought: no slots allocated - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 2 slots will be allocated vogon: 2 slots will be allocated earth: 2 slots will be allocated deep-thought: 2 slots will be allocated This commit was SVN r5894.
2005-05-31 20:36:53 +04:00
map->procs = malloc(sizeof(orte_rmaps_base_proc_t*) * app->num_procs);
if(NULL == map->procs) {
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
ORTE_ERROR_LOG(ORTE_ERR_OUT_OF_RESOURCE);
rc = ORTE_ERR_OUT_OF_RESOURCE;
goto cleanup;
}
if ( 0 < app->num_map ) {
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
/** If the user has specified a mapping for this app_context, then we
* create a working node list that contains only those nodes.
*/
if (ORTE_SUCCESS != (rc = orte_rmaps_base_get_mapped_targets(&mapped_node_list, app, &master_node_list))) {
ORTE_ERROR_LOG(rc);
goto cleanup;
}
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
working_node_list = &mapped_node_list;
/* Set cur_node_item to point to the first node in the specified list to be used */
cur_node_item = opal_list_get_first(working_node_list);
}
else {
/** no mapping was specified, so we are going to just use everything that was
* allocated to us. We don't need to update cur_node_item in this case since it
* is always pointing to something in the master_node_list - we'll just pick up
* from wherever we last stopped.
*/
working_node_list = &master_node_list;
}
/* Make assignments */
(copied from a mail that has a lengthy description of this commit) I spoke with Tim about this the other day -- he gave me the green light to go ahead with this, but it turned into a bigger job than I thought it would be. I revamped how the default RAS scheduling and round_robin RMAPS mapping occurs. The previous algorithms were pretty brain dead, and ignored the "slots" and "max_slots" tokens in hostfiles. I considered this a big enough problem to fix it for the beta (because there is currently no way to control where processes are launched on SMPs). There's still some more bells and whistles that I'd like to implement, but there's no hurry, and they can go on the trunk at any time. My patches below are for what I considered "essential", and do the following: - honor the "slots" and "max-slots" tokens in the hostfile (and all their synonyms), meaning that we allocate/map until we fill slots, and if there are still more processes to allocate/map, we keep going until we fill max-slots (i.e., only oversubscribe a node if we have to). - offer two different algorithms, currently supported by two new options to orterun. Remember that there are two parts here -- slot allocation and process mapping. Slot allocation controls how many processes we'll be running on a node. After that decision has been made, process mapping effectively controls where the ranks of MPI_COMM_WORLD (MCW) are placed. Some of the examples given below don't make sense unless you remember that there is a difference between the two (which makes total sense, but you have to think about it in terms of both things): 1. "-bynode": allocates/maps one process per node in a round-robin fashion until all slots on the node are taken. If we still have more processes after all slots are taken, then keep going until all max-slots are taken. Examples: - The hostfile: eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -bynode -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until each node's max_slots is hit, of course) - orterun -bynode -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4, 6 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 2. "-byslot" (this is the default if you don't specify -bynode): greedily takes all available slots on a node for a job before moving on to the next node. If we still have processes to allocate/schedule, then oversubscribe all nodes equally (i.e., go round robin on all nodes until each node's max_slots is hit). Examples: - The hostfile eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1 vogon: MCW ranks 2, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until max_slots is hit) - orterun -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2, 3 vogon: MCW ranks 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 The above examples are fairly contrived, and it's not clear from them that you can get different allocation answers in all cases (the mapping differences are obvious). Consider the following allocation example: - The hostfile eddie count=4 vogon count=4 earth count=4 deep-thought count=4 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 4 slots will be allocated vogon: 4 slots will be allocated earth: no slots allocated deep-thought: no slots allocated - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 2 slots will be allocated vogon: 2 slots will be allocated earth: 2 slots will be allocated deep-thought: 2 slots will be allocated This commit was SVN r5894.
2005-05-31 20:36:53 +04:00
if (bynode) {
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
rc = map_app_by_node(app, map, jobid, vpid_start, rank, working_node_list, &max_used_nodes);
(copied from a mail that has a lengthy description of this commit) I spoke with Tim about this the other day -- he gave me the green light to go ahead with this, but it turned into a bigger job than I thought it would be. I revamped how the default RAS scheduling and round_robin RMAPS mapping occurs. The previous algorithms were pretty brain dead, and ignored the "slots" and "max_slots" tokens in hostfiles. I considered this a big enough problem to fix it for the beta (because there is currently no way to control where processes are launched on SMPs). There's still some more bells and whistles that I'd like to implement, but there's no hurry, and they can go on the trunk at any time. My patches below are for what I considered "essential", and do the following: - honor the "slots" and "max-slots" tokens in the hostfile (and all their synonyms), meaning that we allocate/map until we fill slots, and if there are still more processes to allocate/map, we keep going until we fill max-slots (i.e., only oversubscribe a node if we have to). - offer two different algorithms, currently supported by two new options to orterun. Remember that there are two parts here -- slot allocation and process mapping. Slot allocation controls how many processes we'll be running on a node. After that decision has been made, process mapping effectively controls where the ranks of MPI_COMM_WORLD (MCW) are placed. Some of the examples given below don't make sense unless you remember that there is a difference between the two (which makes total sense, but you have to think about it in terms of both things): 1. "-bynode": allocates/maps one process per node in a round-robin fashion until all slots on the node are taken. If we still have more processes after all slots are taken, then keep going until all max-slots are taken. Examples: - The hostfile: eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -bynode -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until each node's max_slots is hit, of course) - orterun -bynode -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4, 6 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 2. "-byslot" (this is the default if you don't specify -bynode): greedily takes all available slots on a node for a job before moving on to the next node. If we still have processes to allocate/schedule, then oversubscribe all nodes equally (i.e., go round robin on all nodes until each node's max_slots is hit). Examples: - The hostfile eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1 vogon: MCW ranks 2, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until max_slots is hit) - orterun -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2, 3 vogon: MCW ranks 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 The above examples are fairly contrived, and it's not clear from them that you can get different allocation answers in all cases (the mapping differences are obvious). Consider the following allocation example: - The hostfile eddie count=4 vogon count=4 earth count=4 deep-thought count=4 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 4 slots will be allocated vogon: 4 slots will be allocated earth: no slots allocated deep-thought: no slots allocated - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 2 slots will be allocated vogon: 2 slots will be allocated earth: 2 slots will be allocated deep-thought: 2 slots will be allocated This commit was SVN r5894.
2005-05-31 20:36:53 +04:00
} else {
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
rc = map_app_by_slot(app, map, jobid, vpid_start, rank, working_node_list, &max_used_nodes);
(copied from a mail that has a lengthy description of this commit) I spoke with Tim about this the other day -- he gave me the green light to go ahead with this, but it turned into a bigger job than I thought it would be. I revamped how the default RAS scheduling and round_robin RMAPS mapping occurs. The previous algorithms were pretty brain dead, and ignored the "slots" and "max_slots" tokens in hostfiles. I considered this a big enough problem to fix it for the beta (because there is currently no way to control where processes are launched on SMPs). There's still some more bells and whistles that I'd like to implement, but there's no hurry, and they can go on the trunk at any time. My patches below are for what I considered "essential", and do the following: - honor the "slots" and "max-slots" tokens in the hostfile (and all their synonyms), meaning that we allocate/map until we fill slots, and if there are still more processes to allocate/map, we keep going until we fill max-slots (i.e., only oversubscribe a node if we have to). - offer two different algorithms, currently supported by two new options to orterun. Remember that there are two parts here -- slot allocation and process mapping. Slot allocation controls how many processes we'll be running on a node. After that decision has been made, process mapping effectively controls where the ranks of MPI_COMM_WORLD (MCW) are placed. Some of the examples given below don't make sense unless you remember that there is a difference between the two (which makes total sense, but you have to think about it in terms of both things): 1. "-bynode": allocates/maps one process per node in a round-robin fashion until all slots on the node are taken. If we still have more processes after all slots are taken, then keep going until all max-slots are taken. Examples: - The hostfile: eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -bynode -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until each node's max_slots is hit, of course) - orterun -bynode -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4, 6 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 2. "-byslot" (this is the default if you don't specify -bynode): greedily takes all available slots on a node for a job before moving on to the next node. If we still have processes to allocate/schedule, then oversubscribe all nodes equally (i.e., go round robin on all nodes until each node's max_slots is hit). Examples: - The hostfile eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1 vogon: MCW ranks 2, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until max_slots is hit) - orterun -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2, 3 vogon: MCW ranks 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 The above examples are fairly contrived, and it's not clear from them that you can get different allocation answers in all cases (the mapping differences are obvious). Consider the following allocation example: - The hostfile eddie count=4 vogon count=4 earth count=4 deep-thought count=4 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 4 slots will be allocated vogon: 4 slots will be allocated earth: no slots allocated deep-thought: no slots allocated - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 2 slots will be allocated vogon: 2 slots will be allocated earth: 2 slots will be allocated deep-thought: 2 slots will be allocated This commit was SVN r5894.
2005-05-31 20:36:53 +04:00
}
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
(copied from a mail that has a lengthy description of this commit) I spoke with Tim about this the other day -- he gave me the green light to go ahead with this, but it turned into a bigger job than I thought it would be. I revamped how the default RAS scheduling and round_robin RMAPS mapping occurs. The previous algorithms were pretty brain dead, and ignored the "slots" and "max_slots" tokens in hostfiles. I considered this a big enough problem to fix it for the beta (because there is currently no way to control where processes are launched on SMPs). There's still some more bells and whistles that I'd like to implement, but there's no hurry, and they can go on the trunk at any time. My patches below are for what I considered "essential", and do the following: - honor the "slots" and "max-slots" tokens in the hostfile (and all their synonyms), meaning that we allocate/map until we fill slots, and if there are still more processes to allocate/map, we keep going until we fill max-slots (i.e., only oversubscribe a node if we have to). - offer two different algorithms, currently supported by two new options to orterun. Remember that there are two parts here -- slot allocation and process mapping. Slot allocation controls how many processes we'll be running on a node. After that decision has been made, process mapping effectively controls where the ranks of MPI_COMM_WORLD (MCW) are placed. Some of the examples given below don't make sense unless you remember that there is a difference between the two (which makes total sense, but you have to think about it in terms of both things): 1. "-bynode": allocates/maps one process per node in a round-robin fashion until all slots on the node are taken. If we still have more processes after all slots are taken, then keep going until all max-slots are taken. Examples: - The hostfile: eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -bynode -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until each node's max_slots is hit, of course) - orterun -bynode -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 2, 4, 6 vogon: MCW ranks 1, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 2. "-byslot" (this is the default if you don't specify -bynode): greedily takes all available slots on a node for a job before moving on to the next node. If we still have processes to allocate/schedule, then oversubscribe all nodes equally (i.e., go round robin on all nodes until each node's max_slots is hit). Examples: - The hostfile eddie slots=2 max-slots=4 vogon slots=4 max-slots=8 - orterun -np 6 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1 vogon: MCW ranks 2, 3, 4, 5 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2 vogon: MCW ranks 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 -> the algorithm oversubscribes all nodes "equally" (until max_slots is hit) - orterun -np 12 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: MCW ranks 0, 1, 2, 3 vogon: MCW ranks 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 The above examples are fairly contrived, and it's not clear from them that you can get different allocation answers in all cases (the mapping differences are obvious). Consider the following allocation example: - The hostfile eddie count=4 vogon count=4 earth count=4 deep-thought count=4 - orterun -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 4 slots will be allocated vogon: 4 slots will be allocated earth: no slots allocated deep-thought: no slots allocated - orterun -bynode -np 8 -hostfile hostfile a.out eddie: 2 slots will be allocated vogon: 2 slots will be allocated earth: 2 slots will be allocated deep-thought: 2 slots will be allocated This commit was SVN r5894.
2005-05-31 20:36:53 +04:00
if (ORTE_SUCCESS != rc) {
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
ORTE_ERROR_LOG(rc);
goto cleanup;
}
rank += app->num_procs;
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
/** cleanup the mapped_node_list, if necessary */
if (0 < app->num_map) {
/** before we get rid of the mapped_node_list, we first need to update
* corresponding entries in the master_node_list so we accurately
* track the usage of slots. Also, any node that was "used up" will have
* been removed from the mapped_node_list - we now also must ensure that
* such a node is removed from the master_node_list.
*
* Clearly, there will be a performance penalty in doing all these
* operations to maintain data integrity. However, the case where
* someone maps processes this specifically is considered the
* atypical one, so penalizing it may not be a major issue.
*
* Still, some effort to improve the efficiency of this process
* may be in order for the future.
*/
while (NULL != (item = opal_list_remove_first(&mapped_node_list))) {
node = (orte_ras_node_t*)item;
/** if the node was still on the mapped_node_list, then it hasn't
* been moved to the fully_used_node list - find it on the
* master_node_list and update the slots_inuse count there
*/
for (item2 = opal_list_get_first(&master_node_list);
item2 != opal_list_get_end(&master_node_list);
item2 = opal_list_get_next(item2) ) {
node2 = (orte_ras_node_t*)item2;
if (0 == strcmp(node2->node_name, node->node_name)) {
node2->node_slots_inuse = node->node_slots_inuse;
break;
}
}
OBJ_RELEASE(item);
}
/** that updated everything that wasn't fully used up while
* processing the specific map. Now we have to ensure that
* any nodes that were used up (and hence, transferred to the
* max_used_node list) are removed from the master_node_list
* No really nice way to do this - we just have to run through
* the two lists and remove any duplicates.
*/
while (NULL != (item = opal_list_remove_first(&max_used_nodes))) {
node = (orte_ras_node_t*)item;
for (item2 = opal_list_get_first(&master_node_list);
item2 != opal_list_get_end(&master_node_list);
item2 = opal_list_get_next(item2) ) {
node2 = (orte_ras_node_t*)item2;
/** if we have a match, then remove the entry from the
* master_node_list
*/
if (0 == strcmp(node2->node_name, node->node_name)) {
opal_list_remove_item(&master_node_list, item2);
break;
}
}
/** now put that node on the fully_used_nodes list */
opal_list_append(&fully_used_nodes, &node->super);
}
} else {
/** this mapping wasn't specified, so all we have to do is add any nodes
* that were used up in the mapping to the fully_used_nodes list - they
* were already removed from the master_node_list when we did the mapping.
*/
opal_list_join(&fully_used_nodes, opal_list_get_end(&fully_used_nodes), &max_used_nodes);
}
}
/* save mapping to the registry */
if(ORTE_SUCCESS != (rc = orte_rmaps_base_set_map(jobid, &mapping))) {
goto cleanup;
}
/* save vpid start/range on the job segment */
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
if (ORTE_SUCCESS != (rc = orte_rmaps_base_set_vpid_range(jobid,vpid_start,num_procs))) {
ORTE_ERROR_LOG(rc);
goto cleanup;
}
/** join the master_node_list and fully_used_list so that all info gets updated */
opal_list_join(&master_node_list, opal_list_get_end(&master_node_list), &fully_used_nodes);
/** save the modified node information so we can start from the right
* place next time through
*/
if (ORTE_SUCCESS != (rc = orte_rmaps_base_update_node_usage(&master_node_list))) {
ORTE_ERROR_LOG(rc);
}
cleanup:
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
while(NULL != (item = opal_list_remove_first(&master_node_list))) {
OBJ_RELEASE(item);
}
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
OBJ_DESTRUCT(&master_node_list);
while(NULL != (item = opal_list_remove_first(&mapping))) {
OBJ_RELEASE(item);
}
OBJ_DESTRUCT(&mapping);
This patch fixes several issues relating to comm_spawn and N1GE. In particular, it does the following: 1. Modifies the RAS framework so it correctly stores and retrieves the actual slots in use, not just those that were allocated. Although the RAS node structure had storage for the number of slots in use, it turned out that the base function for storing and retrieving that information ignored what was in the field and simply set it equal to the number of slots allocated. This has now been fixed. 2. Modified the RMAPS framework so it updates the registry with the actual number of slots used by the mapping. Note that daemons are still NOT counted in this process as daemons are NOT mapped at this time. This will be fixed in 2.0, but will not be addressed in 1.x. 3. Added a new MCA parameter "rmaps_base_no_oversubscribe" that tells the system not to oversubscribe nodes even if the underlying environment permits it. The default is to oversubscribe if needed and the underlying environment permits it. I'm sure someone may argue "why would a user do that?", but it turns out that (looking ahead to dynamic resource reservations) sometimes users won't know how many nodes or slots they've been given in advance - this just allows them to say "hey, I'd rather not run if I didn't get enough". 4. Reorganizes the RMAPS framework to more easily support multiple components. A lot of the logic in the round_robin mapper was very valuable to any component - this has been moved to the base so others can take advantage of it. 5. Added a new test program "hello_nodename" - just does "hello_world" but also prints out the name of the node it is on. 6. Made the orte_ras_node_t object a full ORTE data type so it can more easily be copied, packed, etc. This proved helpful for the RMAPS code reorganization and might be of use elsewhere too. This commit was SVN r10697.
2006-07-10 18:10:21 +04:00
OBJ_DESTRUCT(&max_used_nodes);
OBJ_DESTRUCT(&fully_used_nodes);
OBJ_DESTRUCT(&mapped_node_list);
return rc;
}
static int orte_rmaps_rr_finalize(void)
{
return ORTE_SUCCESS;
}
orte_rmaps_base_module_t orte_rmaps_round_robin_module = {
orte_rmaps_rr_map,
orte_rmaps_rr_finalize
};